I think this will always be an endless discussion about which one is better, right?
I admit it, the gamer chair looks nicer. But is it really the most comfortable?
I’ve had both, and in my own experience, I liked the ergonomic one much more. Its design is more minimalist. But it matched my setup because I already had something minimalist. I don’t even like RGB.
I used to have a gamer chair and I was always having back pain. Playing for more than 2 hours was simply impossible without taking long breaks.
I recommend going to a store and trying all the chairs. But pay close attention to the ergonomic chairs.
I think gamer chairs are just a trend. They weren’t made for your comfort, but to look good. Just a fashion effect.
Choose what’s best for you.